An Easter Lamb Cake is a popular centerpiece in many Polish homes. It’s a tradition that followed the Polish diaspora to the United States. If you want to try one, I have the recipe and decorating ideas, my own and others.
Symbolism behind the lamb cake
In the Gospel of John, Jesus is referred to as the Lamb of God, a phrase that’s used in Christian prayers and liturgy.
Since the Middle Ages, the visual image of the lamb has most often been depicted holding a pennant or banner of a red cross on a white background, which represents the Risen Christ.
Another common accessory for the lamb is a red ribbon around its neck. the color representing the blood of Christ.
In Poland, the lamb makes many appearances at Easter. In addition to the lamb cake, there are also butter lambs that have been carved or molded, and sugar lambs are a popular treat for children.
The lamb cake pan
The 3-D lamb cakes are made by baking in a 2-part cake mold. Some are fortunate to have antique cast iron pans that have been passed down in the families.
Modern cake pan makers Nordic Ware and Wilton both make a lamb cake mold. I bought the Nordic Ware pan on Amazon.
I’ve also been told that the lamb cake pans can often be found at garage sales and thrift shops. I guess there are some that only want to make their lamb cake once. 😉
Polish Housewife participates in the Amazon Associate program, and purchases via Amazon links below generate a commission.
The right cake for your lamb cake pan
I’ve used my favorite pound cake recipe. It’s a dense cake that strong enough to keep its shape and the ears attached as your decorating. I find this a simple recipe, but if you prefer to use a mix, be sure it’s a pound cake.
Most moist, pudding in the mix, cake mixes have a texture that’s too soft for this 3-d cake. Whatever cake you’re using, let me encourage to you use this Polish trick when preparing the pan.
Butter the pan and then sprinkle with (unseasoned) breadcrumbs. It guarantees perfect release from the pan.
Decorating your lamb cake
You’ve probably seen this photo making the rounds on Facebook and Pinterest showing the perfect lamb cake and, shall we say, a more rustic version. Don’t let it deter you; follow my lead and you’ll have a no-fail Easter Lamb Cake!
Liz from FarmWifeCooks.com presents three options for decorating lamb cakes. I especially like the simple sophistication of her cake dusted in powdered sugar and with sugared berries.
I used her technique for dipping the face in a glaze for a smooth finish and no broken ears from trying to spread frosting on them. I’ve opted for swirls of piped buttercream because I just enjoy piping, and I can always use some practice.
Structurally, the weakest part of the cake will be the ears. Retro Ruth has a suggestion on how you can add support to this vulnerable area before baking the batter in this post. Something I read too late, and thankfully didn’t need.
As for the eyes, I had originally purchased a bag of licorice jelly beans, which we ate before I made the cake. By the time I replenished the jelly bean supply, the only thing they had was a mixed bag of jelly bellies. Which turned out to be perfect, I could have used black, but I think the brown looked better.
You might also choose to add something to your plain molded pound cake. One option is to carefully slice the body of the lamb cake into thick layers horizontally, spread a thin layer of warmed jam (makes it more spreadable) or a scant layer of lemon curd in between the layers and reassemble before frosting.
The decorating process shouldn’t be rushed. A chilled or frozen cake will be stronger and hold up better as you’re applying whatever you decide to do. Soon after I piped a row or two underneath the lamb’s chin, the frosting slide down about an inch – into the fridge with the cake and the piping bag for about 5 minutes.
I just piped new swirls where they belonged. This might have happened because the glaze of the face was not completely dry.
Whether you’re serving a lamb cake or a mazurek, I wish you and yours a joyous celebration.
Smacznego!
Lois
Print
No-fail Easter Lamb Cake
- Prep Time: 90 min active (plus at least an hour of chilling time for cake)
- Cook Time: 60 min
- Total Time: 47 minute
- Yield: Serves 8 - 10 1x
- Category: dessert
- Method: baking
- Cuisine: Polish
Description
A sturdy pound cake baked in a lamb shaped mold, a delicious centerpiece for Easter
Ingredients
for cake:
- 1/2 cup butter, softened
- 1 cup sugar
- 2 eggs
- 1 1/2 cups flour
- 1/2 teaspoon salt
- 1/2 teaspoon baking powder
- 1/4 teaspoon baking soda
- 1/2 cup buttermilk (or 1 teaspoon vinegar and enough milk to make 1/2 cup)
- 1 teaspoon vanilla
- butter and breadcrumbs to prepare pan
for the frosting:
- 1 cup butter
- 1/2 cup shortening (not something I normally use in cooking, but it helps with the “buttercream” texture)
- 6 cups powdered sugar
- 1 teaspoon vanilla
- 3 – 5 tablespoons milk & more for glaze
- jelly beans for eyes
Instructions
for cake:
- Preheat oven to 325
- Cream butter and sugar, add eggs one at a time
- Combine dry ingredients and add to batter alternating with buttermilk and vanilla
- Prepare pans by spreading lightly with butter and dusting with dried breadcrumbs
- Pour batter into the bottom of your two cake pans, assemble according to direction on your lamb cake mold
- Bake for approximately one hour
- Cool the cake for 10 minutes, remove from pan
- Cool to room temp and refrigerate
for frosting:
- Mix butter, shortening, powdered sugar, vanilla, and just 3 tablespoons of milk, gradually adding more milk until the consistency is similar to light and fluffy mashed potatoes, it should be stiff enough to hold its shape when you pipe it, but soft enough to pipe easily
- Place about 1/2 cup in a small deep bowl and blend in enough milk to make a thick glaze, the texture should be thicker than heavy cream, kind of like a thin pancake batter
- Dip the lambs face into the glaze, covering the face and front side of the ears, and allow the glaze to drip off (I occasionally gave it a wipe to help the process)
- Add a small amount of frosting to the center of your serving platter, place the lamb on top, this will kind of glue it to the plate, I do this with all cakes, but it’s especially helpful with this top-heavy cake
- Add a star tip to a piping bag and pipe swirls of frosting onto the lamb’s body
- If desired, use food coloring to tint a small amount of the frosting, literally a tablespoon or two, a light pink or peach color, use this to pipe the inside of the ears and nose
- Add jelly beans for eyes, I used a plastic straw and pushed it into the cake where I wanted the eyes to be, it gave me an opening to push the jelly beans into
- Refrigerate until you’re ready to put it on the table
Notes
To present your lamb cake on a bed of green grass, mix shredded coconut with a little green food coloring (I used two bags of coconut)
Keywords: Polish Easter, No-fail Lamb Cake
An accountant by trade and a food blogger since 2009, Lois Britton fell in love with Polish cuisine during the years she lived in Poznań, Poland. As the creator of PolishHousewife.com, she loves connecting readers with traditional Polish recipes. Lois has a graduate certificate in Food Writing and Photography from the University of South Florida. She is the author of The Polish Housewife Cookbook, available on Amazon and on her website.
AGH
I’m excited to try this recipe. I don’t have time or enough stomachs around my house to eat a mistake lamb, so it will be a one attempt effort. If it is truly a No-Fail Easter Lamb. I’ll post my results. Happy Easter to all.
polishhousewife
Keeping my fingers crossed for you!
Carly
Cons: I have a vintage Wilton lamb cake pan, and this recipe at regular size (1x) didn’t quite fill the bottom half of the pan, so I wondered if it would actually rise enough to fill out the other pan. I decided to give it a try, but unfortunately it did not. It rose enough that the lamb stands up ok, but it is not as thick and it doesn’t have any of the contours that it should on its back. I think that 2x would be too much.
Pros: It came out of the pan well and seems like a good density, so I know it will hold up. It’s not Easter yet so I can’t say anything about the taste yet!
★★
polishhousewife
There are different lamb molds out there of differing sizes. I hope you enjoyed the cake.
Becky G
How far ahead can I make this? Will it keep for two days? Should it be refrigerated until a couple hours before serving? I’ve never made one before and I’m nervous since I”m not really a baker.
polishhousewife
It will keep for a couple of days. I would wrap in foil or plastic and regrigerate until, as you suggest, a couple of hours before serving.
Mary Anne
This looks like a great recipe. Is the scale of 1x (versus 2x, 3x) enough or for this lamb cake mold?
polishhousewife
I didn’t need to double the recipe, one batch was enough.
Yvonne
This made an enormous amount of batter, and I wondered why so much frosting. Then I realized I pressed x3 At the top of the recipe and it tripled the amount. I thought I was enlarging the font!!
Now we have two extra cakes! My granddaughter and I had fun. I’m freezing it tonight to decorate tomorrow.
polishhousewife
LOL, they’ll freeze well!
Charlotte Placko
Made this recipe. It was perfect & really good. I used to use a box pound cake mix but this is a winner.
★★★★★
Cindy Rodriguez
I have this cake in the oven now.
I didn’t have bread crumbs, so I made my own-we will see how this turns out. I’m curious about the butter, seems it will burn? I’ll follow up with the results.
EA
If you are filling 2 halves of a Nordic Ware mold, make twice the quantity of this recipe. I didn’t and I regretted it.
Faustina
What do u mean by 2 halves? Was there enough batter for one lamb cake, made the normal way?
Cindy Rodriguez
It came out of the pan easily!! I used homemade bread crumbs.
★★★★★
polishhousewife
Hurray!
Rebecca Webb
I have a vintage (1974) Wilton 3D bunny mold that was my mom’s and I had never used. I made my normal dense cake recipe that I have used hundreds of times for Wilton shaped pans and baked it at 350 for 45 minutes and it came crashing down. It didn’t fully cook on the inside. I have never had this happen. So I stumbled across this recipe and thought I would try again. I liked that it was a lower temperature for a longer time which made me think that this had to work. I didn’t think that the rabbit could be much different than the lamb, but when I was pouring in the batter I noticed that it didn’t seem to be enough batter. I put it in the pan, put the lid on, and hoped for the best. Well, when it came out, it was flat and had not taken shape of the top pan. After letting it cool, I set it up and its head fell off. There was just not enough of a base of cake to hold up the ears. It is at least cooked all the way through, but the bunny is lying down now instead of sitting up. I’m going to have to experiment again and make more batter.
★★★
polishhousewife
Oh, Rebecca, I’m sorry to hear the bunny is having such a rough time! I think it was a creative solution to have it lying down.
Ann Roach
My lamb ended up being flat on oneside and the neck and head fell off. There definitely wasn’t enough batter
★
AGH
I had no directions with my cake pans so I filled each half and baked for 30 minutes. I “glued” them together with frosting and placed in freezer for an hour before frosting the whole lamb.
I will try it again. I will be careful to grease pans heavily. The halves were tricky to get out. It has to be a stressful time getting a whole lamb out of the pans.
★★★★
Nancy Stark
I am going to try this recipe and I have an old cast iron lamb. I have not made one in over 40 years but remember that you filled half and put the other half on top and that the last 15 to 20 minutes you were to flip the mold over and finish baking. I have been seaching and have not found that technique. HAve you ever heard of that technique before. Thank you in advance.
polishhousewife
I’ve only made a lamb cake once, Nancy, and my mold is aluminum rather than cast iron. I filled the front side of the mold and put the back of the mold on before putting it in the oven.
Cindy Weis
I make the lamb cake every year plus. Tradition on 1st birthdays the birthday baby gets the lambs head. I have made minnie mouse lamb cakes next week its a zombie lamb.
polishhousewife
That sounds great! I would love to see your zombie lamb!
Allison
Hi,
Is there a way to make this cake chocolate flavored without compromising the cake?
polishhousewife
Hi Allison, you could add 1/3 cup unsweetened cocoa to the batter to make it chocolate. You might also add a teaspoon of instant coffee if you have it, dissolved in a tablespoon of hot water with the liquid. Coffee really highlights chocolate flavor. When I worked in a donut shop, we used black coffee to thin the chocolate frosting. The other frosting flavors were done with hot water.
Ruth
this will be my first time making this. Do you fill both halves of the aluminum mold or only one? After baking do the breadcrumbs get brushed off before frosting?
polishhousewife
If you have directions for your cake mold, Ruth, follow those. I filled the bottom of my mold (which was the front of the lamg), the one meant to be on the baking rack and attached the top before baking.
Linda Lankowski
I will try your recipe this year. My mother never made these. (She was Irish and Belgian) and the one time she tried, it was a yellow cake cut into pieces and decorated with coconut. The recipe I have used the two times I made it were pound cake style and came out very dense and dry. I had no concern at all about the ears!
I used plumped raisins for the eyes, and pink jelly beans for the nose, flattened jelly beans were good inside the ears!
Ashley
Could I add red food coloring to the batter to make it red? Need for a Skit at church.
polishhousewife
sure
Baking enthusiast
Like someone else I hit the “2X” button to increase the font size…what a lot of batter! Anyway I made it fit, baked as directed, unmolded it successfully, left for an hour and the thing had collapsed inward. Was raw in the middle. SO… I guess I had too much batter for the time allotted. There was no way to run a tester into the cake to catch this. I am pretty disappointed and am scrapping plans to make another. At least til next year. Then I will look up the recipe that came with the mold.
Thanks anyways.
★★★
Paula Childs
I just bought the Nordic ware lamb pan. Single recipe of cake batter was only enough for one half. I did put on the top (back) but this didn’t fill. I used wooden chopsticks, broken to size, to stabilize neck & ears – good suggestion. Since I only have half, I placed on its “back” on platter & will decorate! My grandson is coming after school to make some pysanky & pierogi!
Ruth Ranieri
This will be my permanent go to lamb recipe. I always had problems with the cake sticking in the mold, no matter how well I prepped it. The butter/bread crumb trick is like magic. No sticking anywhere. Also this is the perfect amount of batter to fill the entire mold front and back when fully baked. I like the lower temperature, longer bake time compared to past recipes. I am so glad I ran across this recipe.
★★★★★
Clementine Jasinski
Just made my Baranek yesterday. Thank you so much for the perfect instructions. I’m just hoping the middle was done. Toothpick came out clean but the middle of the body sunk in. I also forgot to pipe the icing on the back and top of the head, but everyone says it looks great. Can’t wait for us to dig in on Easter Sunday. Now can you suggest a recipe for meat pierogi. Had sone delicious ones in Krakow but can’t seem to find a recipe to match them or the ones my Aunt made. Thanks.
★★★★★
polishhousewife
This is a meat pierogi recipe that I picked up at a cooking class in Warsaw. https://polishhousewife.com/pork-pierogi/
Nicole
Hmmm… this is my first time for a lamb cake not using a boxed pound cake mix. They seem impossible to find them anymore. So I found this recipe. I did 1x and it didn’t quite fill the pan. I had the same problem as Rebecca Webb… After baking it came out pretty flat; did not fill the top pan at all… Will try again using 2x the recipe. If that doesn’t work will just lay the lamb on it side and serve it that way instead of sitting up.
Nancy K
Tried this in my Wilton aluminum lamb mold. Came out of pan easily using butter and flour on pans, but I don’t think there was enough batter because the lamb started reclining towards the back ( nap time? 🙂 I had to devise a “wedgie” to keep it upright! My eggs were large, all ingredients fresh. Any ideas why there didn’t seem to be enough batter?
★★★★
Daniela Michaels
Lovely recipe but just FYI if it helps someone – for a Wilton Stand-Up Lamb mold, you will need to double this recipe. It perfectly creates the front half only if you only do it with the single recipe. I also believe this would likely work best if you baked 2 halves separately and then paste together – not sure if doubling it would rise enough to fill the back while baking but I haven’t tried it yet that way so I could be wrong! We have a lovely skinny lamb for Easter this year so I’ll try again next year – the funny part of doing recipes just once a year 🙂 Delicious and just my learning curve on the amounts.
★★★★★
Elizabeth
Came out of the pan wonderfully, although it wasn’t nearly enough bstter – could have left the back off and it would have been fine because it just barely made it to the top of the face side once baked. Probably should have read the comments first. I opted for dusting with powdered sugar, and used Royal Icing discs leftover from a recent cookie decorating project for the eyes and used a black food color marker for the center of the eyes. Since I seem to always have royal icing made up, I threw some of that undiluted into a zip bag and drew the mouth and nose. Will definitely take another shot at it next year and double the recipe. Thanks for the great tips.
★★★★
Holly Cross
I have made lamb cakes for years. This is the first I have made from scratch, and it was delicious. This pound cake would have been great without any frosting. It is substantial enough to make it easier for the lamb to be supported.
However, the recipe was not enough for my lamb mold. After making it, it did not fill the lamb, and I made an additional half recipe. Even that wasn’t enough, but it did work.
★★★★★
Janet Iwanski
This was always a tradition in my home growing up. I used to make it every year . After my mom passed i no longer dis it. Sadly. My mom used to used dormitory pound cake mix. Cant find anymore and I will try this one next year. I actually put flowers and vunes on the back of my lamb for more decoration. Thanks for sharing.
polishhousewife
I love the idea of using flowers. Thanks for sharing that!
Cal
My cake turned out adorable! The problem was the taste of the cake. I felt like the frosting was cloyingly sweet and the cake was dry. I appreciate all your decorating and baking tips. I might try the cake recipe one more time but would definitely use a less sweet buttercream recipe.
★★★
Lindsay
Wow!!!! I’m shocked at how well this turned out! I have the original aluminum lamb cake from the 1950’s. My grandmother always made this for our 1st birthday. My mom has tried and failed to make for the grandkids and they are always a mess—missing heads, ears, etc! I wanted to make one for my little
Girl’s first birthday and it is PERFECT!!! I am so thankful I came across this recipe.
One tip for some extra strength (found on another recipe)—place toothpicks in the batter of the ears and neck area before baking. This seemingly helped my cake a bunch! Can’t wait to decorate and enjoy at Esther’s party!
★★★★★
Nann
I haven’t made thd lamb cake for a few decades. I see some of my solutions to the cake are being used by a lot of bakers now. We just winged it 50 years ago.
All the recipes I’ve looked at are showing the aluminum pans now. I have a very heavy cast iron pan. Don’t have any directions from over 50 years ago. Time: would it need to bake longer or shorter in the cast iron pan?
The bread crumbs is a unique suggestion. Never heard of that. Will give that a try. Does it make the outside crispy? Butter and bread crumbs, yummy.
Agree with others, box pound cake mix is almost impossible to find. Of course tooth picks in the ears. I used a sishkabob stick from head to toe to hold the head, into the batter.
Looking forward to trying your recipe.
This year, I became the oldest member of my Polish family. My last aunt passed.
I’m the oldest cousin now. 76
Thought I would give the old lamb another go, for the great grandkids. They have never see one b4. See if these old bones can do it.
Happy Easter
Janet kuzma
Best tip ever to use breadcrumbs for the pan. My lamb came out the best ever
★★★★
Lois Britton
I’m thrilled to hear it. I’m making one next week for an event at my church.